Our picks for warm or neutral skintones with blue eyes. Depth of skintone (fair, tan, deep, etc) is irrelevant here, because some people prefer bright shades on pale skin, and some people prefer soft neutrals on very dark skin.
The shades listed in these categories are merely our suggestions for making eye colours stand out. Not all shades are listed within these categories. Your own preferences may vary (we love a bit of vibrant blue shadow to show off blue eyes, but you may not exactly go for that). Major makeup rule: don't wear it if you don't like the way it looks on yourself. :)

Adam & Steve's Loose Eye Shadow
This is a remake of our old shade Mermen, as …$5.90
Size options/Buy

Atomic Afterglow Loose Eye Shadow
Silvery-taupe with highlights of copper and g…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Curiouser and Curiouser! Loose Eye Shadow
From the "Mad Tea Party" collection of half-p…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Dokkálfar Loose Eye Shadow
(Dark Elves) Black filled with hues of pale g…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Dressed To Kill Loose Eye Shadow
Glimmering, glowing deceptive gilded green "d…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Electro-Koi Loose Eye Shadow
Vibrant orange that's loaded with coordin…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Equality Loose Eye Shadow
This is as close to holographic* as we have g…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Fire Opal Loose Eye Shadow
Shimmery, somewhat metallic coppery bronze wi…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Griffonrider Loose Eye Shadow
Slightly metallic gold shot through with turq…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Half-Elf Hottie Loose Eye Shadow
Soft, gently shimmering gold with light purpl…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Hypercool Loose Eye Shadow
Brilliant turquoise shimmer over black (tends…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Parental Advisory Loose Eye Shadow
Vivid shimmery royal purple. Almost two-toned…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Polar Bear Loose Eye Shadow
White-gold, shimmery and soft (brilliant gold…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Sleepy Hollow Loose Eye Shadow
Lush ocean blue with a flash of sage green as…$5.90
Size options/Buy

STFU Loose Eye Shadow
Deep, rich aged copper gleaming with coordina…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Strip Poker Loose Eye Shadow
Medium ocean-blue with an orange/copper shimm…$5.90
Size options/Buy

Týr Loose Eye Shadow
(pron. "teer") Difficult to describe, this is…$5.90
Size options/Buy